Wood Rot on Trim, Sills and Fascia: How to Find It and Fix It
Rot is wood decay caused by fungi, and those fungi need wood that stays damp. Paint can hide it for years, so by the time a sill looks bad the damage is often deeper than it appears. Catching rot early keeps a small carpentry repair from becoming a window, door or framing replacement.
Where to look
Rot almost always starts where water collects, sits on end grain, or cannot dry out.
- Window sills and the bottom ends of window casings
- The bottom of exterior door jambs and brick molding, especially where they meet the threshold
- Fascia boards behind gutters that overflow
- Corner boards and the lowest courses of clapboard near the ground or a roof line
- Porch columns, post bases, railings and stair stringers
- Garage door jambs and the trim along the bottom of garage doors
- Where a deck ledger or porch roof meets the house
How to check
Use a flat screwdriver or an awl. Healthy wood resists and, if it gives at all, splinters in long fibers. Rotted wood lets the tip sink in easily and breaks off in short, crumbly or spongy pieces. Other signs include paint that bubbles or peels repeatedly in one spot, dark staining, a musty smell, and wood that looks swollen or has cracks running across the grain in a checkerboard pattern.
Repair or replace?
Epoxy repair works well for limited damage: a soft corner on a sill, a rotted end on a piece of trim, or a section of an otherwise sound historic part that would be hard to match. The rotted wood is dug out to sound material, the remaining fibers are treated with a liquid epoxy consolidant, and the void is filled with an epoxy paste that can be shaped, sanded and painted.
Replacement is the better choice when rot runs through most of the board, when the piece carries load (a post, a stair stringer, a sill plate, a rim joist), or when it is cheaper to replace a common profile than to rebuild it. Sometimes a "dutchman" repair, where only the damaged length is cut out and a new piece is spliced in, gives the best of both.
Fix the water first
A repair that does not address the moisture source will rot again. Common causes include:
- Overflowing or leaking gutters
- Missing or failed caulk at joints and around windows
- Missing drip edge or flashing above windows, doors and trim
- Sills without enough slope, so water sits on them
- Trim that touches the ground, a roof surface or a deck without a gap
- Lawn sprinklers hitting the house
- Bushes and vines that keep siding from drying
Making the repair last
- Prime new wood on all six sides, including the cut ends, before installing it.
- Leave a small gap where trim meets a horizontal surface so end grain is not sitting in water.
- Consider cellular PVC or composite trim for parts close to the ground or roofs. It does not rot, though it moves with temperature and needs proper fastening.
- Use stainless or hot-dipped galvanized fasteners outdoors.
- Repaint promptly and keep caulk joints maintained.
When it may be more than trim
If the screwdriver sinks into the framing behind the trim, if floors near an exterior door feel soft, or if you see frass (fine wood powder) or winged insects, the problem may involve structural wood or insects like carpenter ants or termites. Those need a closer inspection before any cosmetic work is done.
Need a hand? See our carpentry services or request a free estimate.
This guide is general information for homeowners, written from our experience maintaining homes in Essex County, MA. Every house is different, so have a qualified professional look at anything structural, electrical, plumbing or safety-related. Browse all guides.
Related guides
Ready to get started?
Tell us about the job and we will get back to you with a straight answer on price and timing. Estimates are free.